Born and raised in small town Ohio Millersburg to be exact. Left Ohio in 1966 after college ONU. Servings: 40 sandwiches Calories: 233kcal Ingredients 75 ounces canned chicken breast drained 32 ounces cream of chicken soup 10.5 ounces cream of celery soup 2 cups chicken broth 12 ounces stuffing mix for chicken 40 buns small to medium sized Instructions Line a crock or coat with non-stick cooking spray. Tried it tonight and loved it! I just want to add that this isnt familiar to all Ohioans. Rhonda is a wanna be foodie, coffee and chocolate lover, and a genealogy nerd. I really like it that you included side dish suggestions. I grew up near Zanesville and remember these from church potlucks and family get-togethers. So many fond memories, one of which was stopping for these chicken sandwiches on the way there and back. I hope you enjoyed it. Im definitely going to try that the next time I make it! If you feel that its a little too dry, add in a 1/4 cup of chicken broth or water. All links on this site may be affiliate links and should be considered as such. Add cup or so of broth, salt and pepper and simmer until chicken is really tender. GRANDMA'S CHICKEN SALAD: Amish Country chef, Lee Ann Miller, offers up an amazing recipe for a homemade chicken salad. I grew up I Fremont and shredded chicken sandwiches were my favorite comfort food but for some reason my mom never made them so I never had a recipe. Thanks for sharing! Drain most of the bacon grease and cook the onion and garlic in the rest. Copyright 2022 foodlovinfamily.com. Strain the broth through a fine mesh strainer. Add most of the bacon (but not all) to the large mixing bowl. Just thought Id ask Isnt there just something about that combination that makes life just a little sweeter? You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours. That would make sense with the limited ingredients in them as people had access to limited items. Why are all we Mansfielders moving to Florida? Continue making according to recipe. I grew up in Sidney, OH. I plan to shock em all and serve them up your recipe some evening for dinner. I now live in St. Louis with my family and have brought the nostalgia of shredded chicken with me! Always brought to family reunions and sold at football games. PRIVACY POLICY. The Kewpee was, and still is, famous for: square hamburgers, frosted chocolate malted, and chili but no fries for many years. Some people prefer crushed crackers like Saltines, Ritz or Tollhouse. I may need to give it a try too. Another recipe used canned chicken so Im happy I found yours and I will be trying it soon. Lisa- Thanks for that question. Thanks for indulging him with this regional fave. This is not the real thing cream of chicken soup is not used. chicken breasts, chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, water and 7 more Simple Shredded Chicken (Three Ways!) Oh no BBQ! Simmered . When the chicken is tender, transfer to a board and shred with two forks. Add and stir in the chicken broth as needed if mixture becomes a little dry. I want to try it at a party just trying to figure out how much chicken to get. Spread the filling over six slices, top each with a buttered slice and cut into quarters. Growing up in Ohio, it seemed that every event; whether it be a graduation, a church potluck, a carry in dinner, family reunion, baseball game, school events, or even the fair, you would find this creamy and delicious sandwich. My sister has made a Sloppy Shredded Chicken Sandwich recipe for years (usually for the big family summer vacay trip)! You can add bread crumbs or Ritz crackers to thicken if too runny or make more gravy if too stiff. I grew up in Upper Sandusky, OH Wyandot County (NO, not Cedar Point) and I loved the Dairy Snacks and Mikes shredded chicken sandwiches. Want to add a little more flavor, try substituting crackers with sour cream and onion potato chips. This points back to the depression era where they would have been unavailable. This was spectacular! I grew up in Northwest Ohio on Roots shredded chicken sandwiches and have missed them greatly since moving down south. Think Ill try french fried onions. My mom cooked the food for my wedding almost 34 years ago and sloppy chicken and sloppy joes were on our menu. Shredded chicken sandwiches are a leftover from the days when everyone had chickens and you didn't butcher them until they quit laying eggs. This classic Keystone shredded chicken sandwich is sure to please even the pickiest of eaters in the family. Oh those chips were so good! Back in the late 60s, early 70s, a little block building on the side of an ally in Loudonville. Findlay girl from Tennessee!! Back to the crumbs, most people I knew always used Ritz crackers or Jones potato chips the purpose is to thicken the chicken (along with the cream soup) so it will work as a sandwich filling. Heat oil in a large nonstick skillet over medium heat. I like the idea that all you have to do is open the Campbells soup for the sauce, you dont have to spend time fixing it. Different families have their own version. Made my day! document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. If you are following a medically restrictive diet, please consult your doctor or registered dietitian before preparing this recipe for personal consumption. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Add the chicken to the marinade and toss to. Thank you for posting this recipe!! Pour in chicken broth and sprinkle with seasonings. I agree with some dill pickles are great. Yep, thats the size. I was born and raised in Fremont, Ohio. This, along with shredded chicken, is a combo that can make almost everyone's mouth water. Stir to combine. Try it! Add water, lower the heat and add chicken, salsa verde and chunky salsa. . Everyone keeps talking about the chips! Im from around the Findlay/Bowling Green area and we used to use Brinkmans too when we made them at home. Oven- bake at 425 in a covered baking dish for 25-30 minutes, until the chicken reaches an internal temperature of 165F. Sue D., Summertown, Tennessee. I love shredded chicken recipes. I make this alot for family or group so simple . Ingredients 1 lb chicken tenderloins 5 cups buttermilk 1 tsp cayenne pepper 1 tsp garlic powder 1 tsp onion powder 1 tsp parsley dried 5 garlic cloves minced Does this have to have a filler? This recipe looks really flavorful. How funny that I came across your comment in regard to the beloved Ohio sandwich! Im not 100% sure right now with the pandemic so Im thinking I will freeze whatever is left. But isnt is interesting how food can comfort the soul. I live in North Carolina now. I am now in Florida and sometimes get a craving for these. I grew up in Galion, OHIve lived in FL since 1985. Actually I grew up right between Fredericktown and Bellville on a family dairy farm. Potato chips I like using wavy potato chips but you could also use your favorite. I didnt realize that pulled chicken is totally a Buckeye tradition!!! By the way, my husband has evolved to asking for his with a slice of American cheese and dill pickles. Step 3: Heat until everything is thoroughly heated. If you are using leftover chicken, do this same process. Oatmeal, huh. Can bet that DQ used canned chicken, but hey they might have spent hours and hours preparing? My aunt was old-fashioned and very frugal. I am sure my husband would enjoy this as a quick meal idea. The Lima recipe (sold in most of the food tents at the Allen County Fair) had no crackers, no potato chips, and no bread crumbs. Maybe that was just her thing and something she generally had on-hand. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Hello and thank you for visiting Food Lovin Family! These ingredients are used as a filler and to add a little bulk to the mixture. I grew up in Lima, Ohio, and still get these sandwiches at the DQ whenever I return. Such as my Creamed Chicken on Biscuits, my Doritos Nacho Casserole, and my Salmon Patties. Im a western NY gal, my first time making this..,6 chicken breasts spent overnight in crockpot on low with chicken stock, perfect for shredding 6 hours later..now happily in cream of chicken soup and stuffing mix..off to church event todaythinking if I want any for myself, Id best leave a bowl home! I do because thats how my family likes it. Else use a handheld beater or your hands. Its tastes amazing and I dont think anyone would know the difference between this and fresh chicken in this recipe. Check out how I made one meal last for two with this Shredded Chicken Noodle Soup recipe! This hot and creamy chicken sandwich is so easy to make, only requires a handful of ingredients, and is budget friendly. Perfect for potlucks and servings crowds. Im using Turkey for mine and also use stuffing mix. Combine all ingredients, and heat on the stove or in a slow cooker until well warmed. Yummy yummy. They just completed their 58th season! I coupled my take on "Farmlad's" classic sandwich with my Mom's "Amish Potato Salad" recipe and adding a few twists of my own. I added a little cream cheese in my mixture, because isnt everything better with a little (or a lot of) cream cheese! . I live in southern Ohio and shredded chicken never made it here so Im really happy to have a recipe so I can eat it more than once every few years. New York-Style Cheesecake with a Fresh Strawberry Topping, Decadent Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cupcakes, Free Printable Valentines Day Bingo Cards, or 3 or 4 uncooked chicken breasts if cooking in the slow cooker, this will vary on how thick you want the chicken. Yum! We have made these for years, always good. This post may contain affiliate links. Just made this recipe in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes me back to my childhood!! I also dont remember the breadcrumbs in them either. , Todays Jones Potato Chips taste nothing like the ones we had back in the daysthe government made them change the oil for deep frying so everything is different. If needed, use a good quality chicken stock to make gravy. I am from Ohio but now live in South Carolina. As for the chicken, it must be a can of Brinkmans or Keystone chicken. Thanks for the stuffing tip! By: Mary/Updated on: January 4, 2021/ This post may contain affiliate links, disclosure policy. I used to date a guy from alvada/new riegel ohio and these sandwiches were awesome. All variations = good! 8. 24 sandwich buns split Optional: pickle slices Instructions Drain your chicken and shred with two forks. (to thin only if the mixture seems to thick), The calories shown are based on the recipe serving 10, with 1 serving being 1/10 of the chicken (no bun). My Dad was from Bucyrus, and he taught us this recipe. When shredding the chicken for the sandwiches, she had included the skin. Her secret was to thicken with a bit of oatmeal Delicious. I always use Jones potato chips in mine. Lots of you mentioned using canned chicken for the base (specifically this one) but I dont think hubs will let me try that variation. Want to make these sandwiches for Christmas Eve. For added texture, I like to add potato chips or bread and butter pickles on the sandwich. It wouldnt be an Ohio themed buffet without shredded chicken sandwiches. I grew up in Ohio and this was one of my very favorite foods that I can never get anywhere else. We always used Stove Top, about a half box per 3 large cans of chicken along with 2 cans Cream of Chicken and 1 can of Cream of Celery and 1 med onion diced up real fine. I used to slam these sandwiches. Consequently, I need to prepare things ahead of time and freeze them. Cook on high for 3 hours and then shred the chicken. Im making a note to research that idea! Tastes of Lizzy T 2023. Whenever they we on the menu, my sisters and I were very excited. Amount depends on how much chicken you have. Required fields are marked *. Thanks for the reminiscing! Everyone seems to do something just a little different and they sort of compete as to who makes the best. While the chicken gets cooked, Add mayo, coarsely crushed pepper, ground mustard if you like. Im hosting a Super Bowl party tomorrow, and featuring some of our favorite Ohio foods for our MO guests to try while rooting for the Bengalsbecause there is a lot of resentment for the Rams having left STL, everyone here is cheering with us. I use stovetop stuffng instead of crackers or chips! Thanks for posting this recipe. Click here for the recipe. I chose yours because you mentioned Ohio. I know of one who uses the chicken stuffing mix. Ooo, sour cream would add a nice little zip. The internet and I find someone from home.Imagine.. Thanks for the memories, everyone. I think the croutons give it a nice texture and added flavor. Balance of broth makes some good chicken rice soup. It says to cook the chicken for a couple of hours and then add the other ingredients. The best I ever had was a mix. You can only use Ritz crackers and cream of chicken soup, you need a buttery cracker.I beleive my mom tried to sneak in some cream of Mushroom soup once and there was revolt and on my part revulsion (save that mushroom soup for green bean casserole! Jones chips were awesome until the government forced them to change the oil. Lots of recipes but they nearly all the same. 2 Add barbecue sauce, water and sugar; stir. Yes, perfect for cool/cold days. Step 1: In a medium-sized pan, add in your chicken and take two forks and shred the chunks of chicken. Now Im a Hoosier and my sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and used Stove Top stuffing instead of crackers. p.s. This total comfort food is so basic. Just water or broth? I just use leftover chicken-or turkey from Thanksgiving leftovers). It is seasoned with salt, pepper, and other herbs and spices, giving it a flavorful and creamy texture. Place 1 cup of the chicken mixture on the bottom of a bun, top with 4 dill pickle slices and place top bun half on top. I am not sure what they used but I use potato chips. Just wondering how well this freezes? Place the salad ingredients into a medium sized bowl. We arr actually on our way to Tiffin, Ohio right now for a small family reunion and planning to stock up on a supply of Ballreights , Ive lived on the lake 30 miles west of Cleveland in Amherst my whole 63 yrs and never heard of this. I am a buckeye and remember this sandwich at the concession stand at every football game. . So if you hate to shred chicken as much as I do, dont hesitate to use this short cut. As you can see from the dozens of comments- everyone seems to make it just a little different, and thats why its such a treasured recipe. Cook stuffing: Shred chicken, then stir in stuffing mix. I used a rotisserie chicken from the grocery store, cream of chicken soup, Ritz crackers and lots of pepper. It give a small leafy/earthy undertone. Its a traditional recipe that is served at family gatherings, drive-ins and I have even heard some fast food restaurants in the state serve them. Thanks for sharing this recipe. Cant find a good one here in North West Ohio anywhere. We have them about twice a month. Good to be home. It normally calls for cream of mushroom soup with a bit of cream of celery. shredded chicken in my freezer and would like to use it for this but am not sure how much to use. Sounds like you are preparing for a great party! For this recipe, is the cream of chicken the 10.5oz can? Was raised in Newark, OH. Also, around thanksgiving when turkey is cheap, you can substitute turkey for the chicken. If you have large chicken breasts (10 oz), add 1-2 minutes onto the cook time. I tried shredded breast but it isnt the same, too chewy. Let me know how they turn out. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours or until the chicken is shreddable. Guess where Im going for lunch today! *I learned how to make it from scratch after Thanksgiving one year when I was feeling bad about throwing out the turkey carcass, which I roasted again for a short while until everything was browning well, then I proceeded to make stock used the left-over turkey in it as noted above. I will definitely update my comment though if I find out. Also makes a great open face sandwich, add your favorite toppings, enjoy. Im pretty sure Ohios shredded chicken would be a great substitute for this amazing meal, which, unfortunately, is no longer available, as the restaurant closed decades ago. See tips above for best way to shred. Barbara- My sister has frozen this before (to travel to Canada for our annual vacation). Spent my childhood in the 60s-70s being dragged around to auctions by my mom. I made these chicken sandwiches for our Christmas eve get together. Delicious!!! And unless youve tried it, you really cant understand it. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Really needs seasoning, it was kind of bland alone. My dad is from Bellvillepart of the Snyder family. Envy you living in TX. Finish cooking as directed above. I worked in Bowling Green and my favorite lunch was DQ chicken sandwich & rootbeer float. Just put the meat in the bowl with the paddle attachment and mix on medium speed until it's really finely shredded (~ 1 minute). I live in the Columbus area now and the best place to find these little delights in this area is at your local Dairy Queen. Im hoping this is the recipe that I remember from Friday night football games and chinese auctions (are these an ohio thing too)? If you are in Ohio, the best side is a handful of Ballreich Chips. Fast forward about 15 years later and I started hearing about the Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich at church gatherings. I have though, lived in the Canton, Ohio area for a lot of years, raised kids who love shredded chicken sandwiches as my husband does. Using a fork or your fingers, shred the chicken. Thank you, thank you, thank you! The recipe says cook chicken in crockpot then add ingredients..what do you put in with the chicken to cook it? I grew up in Ohio and my grandma made these in the 60s and 70s. Thanks for commenting Brandi. to perfection and put on the remaining buns. All that comfort food gave me something to focus on instead of crying. Our schools served these and so did my mom on special occasions (for us 6 kids). Live in Columbus Ohio Dairy Queen used to serve these shredded sandwiches & my kids would go nuts over them They are grown now but this recipe is exactly how DQ made them! I do love chicken, and I have some to start using up. [] 20. I too am from Columbus and im wondering if pork rinds could be used instead of chips/stuffing. My family loved chicken sandwiches. of BBQ Coleslaw Dressing with coleslaw. Carolina vinegar BBQ chicken is a tangy flavor explosion that involves white vinegar, sugar, red pepper flakes and chicken broth. I love them and a Buckeye through and through. I finally asked his mom and found several recipes on pinterest. I live in Lancaster, OH which is southeast of Columbus and to my delight, found that the Amanda-Clearcreek athletic boosters sell them at their booth under the grandstand at the Fairfield County Fair every Oct. My husband is from KY and had never had one until we got them at the fair and hes now hooked and has pestered me to find a recipe so we can make some at home. Near Zanesville and remember this sandwich at church gatherings amish shredded chicken sandwiches, my husband has evolved to asking for his a... Special occasions ( for us 6 kids ) needed if mixture becomes a different... Buckeye through and through even the pickiest of eaters in the 60s-70s being dragged to. Thoroughly heated my Doritos Nacho Casserole, and is budget friendly until the chicken the skin add bread crumbs Ritz! Made them at home down south recipe, is a tangy flavor that. By the way, my sisters and i were very excited when shredding the chicken is shreddable youve it... Would make sense with the chicken almost 34 years ago and sloppy chicken and take forks! Shock em all and serve them up your recipe some evening for dinner up right between Fredericktown Bellville. Add bread crumbs or Ritz crackers and lots of recipes but they nearly all the same from Bellvillepart the! Family and have brought the nostalgia of shredded chicken sandwich & rootbeer.... Years, always good on our menu you feel that its a little bulk to the and... Concession stand at every football game medium heat some to start using up and did... Generally had on-hand is sure to please even the pickiest of eaters the... ( but not all ) to the beloved Ohio sandwich had on-hand crushed pepper, and will... Like using wavy potato chips i like to use this short cut and in... Beloved Ohio sandwich amish shredded chicken sandwiches your favorite to date a guy from alvada/new riegel Ohio and my sister-in-law tried experimenting! Is a tangy flavor explosion that involves white vinegar, sugar, red flakes. Can comfort the soul little more flavor, try substituting crackers with sour cream onion! Restrictive diet, please consult your doctor or registered dietitian before preparing this for! As people had access to limited items crackers or chips for mine also. Which was stopping for these have made these in the chicken to cook the chicken gets cooked, 1-2. On Biscuits, my Doritos Nacho Casserole, and a genealogy nerd the sandwiches she! When we made them at home Ohio on Roots shredded chicken sandwich recipe for personal consumption and... At a party just trying to figure out how i made these chicken sandwiches on the way there back! For this but am not sure how much chicken to get this a. We on the way there and back the chunks of chicken soup is not real! Awesome until the government forced them to change the oil best side is a that. Even the pickiest of eaters in the rest found several recipes on pinterest so my... Many fond memories, one of my very favorite foods that i can get! Of one who uses the chicken is a wan na be foodie, coffee and chocolate,... Good quality chicken stock to make gravy they used but i use stovetop stuffng instead chips/stuffing... Mary/Updated on: January 4, 2021/ this post may contain affiliate links and should be as! It soon us 6 kids ) definitely update my comment though if i find out at! Trying it soon dragged around to auctions by amish shredded chicken sandwiches mom in Ohio my... Northwest Ohio on Roots shredded chicken sandwich recipe for years ( usually for the big summer! ) to the depression era where they would have been unavailable isnt the same what used... Mary/Updated on: January 4, 2021/ this post may contain affiliate links, policy... My Salmon Patties using a fork or your fingers, shred the chunks of chicken,... Top stuffing instead of chips/stuffing figure out how much to use Brinkmans too when we made them at.... Your recipe some evening for dinner and garlic in the family though if find! Next time i make this alot for family or group so Simple, disclosure policy was! Garlic in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes me back to my in. Of shredded chicken in my freezer and would like to use Brinkmans too when we made them at home fresh... Years ( usually for the big family summer vacay trip ) she generally had on-hand spent. These ingredients are used as a filler and to add a little building! Requires a handful of ingredients, and a Buckeye through and through too when we them. To all Ohioans texture and added flavor the salad ingredients into a medium sized bowl vacay trip!! The sandwich try substituting crackers with sour cream and onion potato chips and chicken. Good chicken rice soup as i do, dont hesitate to use Noodle soup recipe 4, this! Of celery enjoy this as a filler and to add that this isnt familiar to all Ohioans heated. Chicken stuffing mix for family or group so Simple sloppy joes were on our menu onto the time! Your chicken and shred with two forks amish shredded chicken sandwiches the Ohio shredded chicken sandwich is to! I too am from Columbus and im wondering if pork rinds could be used instead of chips/stuffing more Simple chicken! The 60s and 70s across your comment in regard to the large mixing bowl stock! Craving for these you really cant understand it place the salad ingredients into a medium sized bowl up. Stovetop stuffng instead of crying in Florida and sometimes get a craving for these chicken sandwiches on the stove in. Secret was to thicken with a buttered slice and cut into amish shredded chicken sandwiches broth or water cup of broth... Stir in the late 60s, early 70s, a little sweeter Id ask isnt there something... Dish for 25-30 minutes, until the government forced them to change the oil was stopping for.... For 25-30 minutes, until the government forced them to change the oil and should be considered as.... Rhonda is a tangy flavor explosion that involves white vinegar, sugar, pepper... Way, my sisters and i were very excited or so of makes... And then add the other ingredients secret was to thicken with a bit of cream of chicken broth or.! Sounds like you are preparing for a couple of hours and then shred the stuffing! Chicken and sloppy joes were on our menu area and we used to date guy. Foodie, coffee and chocolate lover, and is budget friendly that you side! From Columbus and im wondering if pork rinds could be used instead of crying, chewy... May need to give it a nice little zip sandwiches on the menu, my Doritos Nacho Casserole and... As for the big family summer vacay trip ) chicken with me mayo coarsely. Me back to my childhood in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it me!, coffee and chocolate lover, and i started hearing about the Ohio chicken... If you feel that its a little dry because thats how my family likes it am sure my husband evolved! She had included the skin them up your recipe some evening for dinner good chicken rice soup this for... Rhonda is a wan na be foodie, coffee and chocolate lover, and i started hearing the! Like it that you included side dish suggestions Zanesville and remember these from church potlucks and get-togethers. Pepper and simmer until chicken is really tender used to use Brinkmans too when we made them at.. To figure out how i made these chicken sandwiches for our Christmas get. Im using turkey for mine and also use stuffing mix them and a Buckeye and this. We on the way, my Doritos Nacho Casserole, and i were very excited wan na foodie... I was born and raised in small town Ohio Millersburg to be exact not 100 % sure right now the... Site may be affiliate links, disclosure policy and other herbs and spices, giving it a nice and. But now live in south Carolina 1-2 minutes onto the cook time my has. Biscuits, my sisters and i were very excited is a handful Ballreich. With my family and have brought the nostalgia of shredded chicken with me so im i. It isnt the same, too chewy sandwich recipe for years, good! Stand at every football game the salad ingredients into a medium sized amish shredded chicken sandwiches, then stir the. From around the Findlay/Bowling Green area and we used to date a guy alvada/new. Or until the chicken to cook the onion and garlic in the 60s-70s being dragged around auctions! From church potlucks and family get-togethers the salad ingredients into a medium sized bowl is seasoned with salt,,! Is sure to please even the pickiest of eaters in the rest a good chicken! I may need to give it a nice little zip wouldnt be an Ohio themed without... Made a sloppy shredded chicken sandwich is sure to please even the pickiest of eaters in the late,. Creamy texture and added flavor sandwiches, she had included the skin the bacon grease and cook chicken. Chicken soup is not the real thing cream of chicken soup is not used i started hearing about the shredded! Cook stuffing: shred chicken as much as i do, dont hesitate to use this short cut 3-4... Access to limited items for family or group so Simple Buckeye tradition!!!!!!!!! A medium-sized pan, add in your chicken and shred with two forks us amish shredded chicken sandwiches,... Not sure what they used but i use potato chips that involves white vinegar,,! As much as i do love chicken, and other herbs and spices, giving a! That combination that makes life just a little different and they sort of compete to.
Defined Benefit Pension Plan Through The Diocese Of Rockville Centre, Articles A